Projected impact
What it should be worth.
22%60-day repeat purchase rate, up from 14%
$1.84Touch 4 revenue per recipient, vs $0.74 for a best-sellers email
+$17,280A month, per 4,000 first-time buyers
| Metric | Control | 60-day journey |
|---|
| Touch 1 open rate | 52% | 68% |
| Skin-type tap rate | n/a | 22% |
| Touch 2 reply rate | n/a | 4.5% |
| Review rate | 5% | 11% |
| Touch 4 revenue per recipient | $0.74 | $1.84 |
| Loyalty sign-ups (Touch 5) | n/a | 9% |
| 60-day repeat rate | 14% | 22% |
| Median days to 2nd order | 41 | 27 |
| Unsubscribe rate | 0.30% | 0.18% |
The maths: +8 points of repeat rate on 4,000 first-time buyers a month = 320 more second orders. 320 × $54 average order = $17,280 a month, about $207,000 a year, before any third order.
How we would measure it: Hypothesis: if a first-time buyer gets four touches that earn trust before two that sell, and no other flow undercuts them, more of them come back within 60 days, and sooner. Validated with a 50/50 hold-out of first-time buyers, read once both groups are 60 days past their first order.
How it's built in Klaviyo and Shopify
Klaviyo's feeds have no "complementary products" type, so the pairing is curated in Shopify and the ranking is predictive in Klaviyo. Merchandising decides the shelf; the algorithm decides the order.
- Shopify: hidden pairing collections such as "Pair · After-Sun", built by tag and unlisted from the storefront.
- Klaviyo catalog: products, prices, stock and collections sync natively, so each pairing collection becomes a filterable category.
- Product feeds: one "may also like" feed per pairing, limited to its category, with a minimum stock of 10 and a best-seller fallback for brand-new profiles.
- Flow: the order's categories route the buyer to the Touch 4 branch whose product block reads the right feed.
- Orchestration: welcome and browse flows exit or pause for new buyers, discount campaigns exclude anyone whose first order was in the last 30 days, and touches 3 to 6 skip anyone who got 2+ emails in the last 3 days.
- Phase 2: when the catalog outgrows hand-built collections, the pairing map moves to a JSON web feed read by a single Touch 4 template.
The pairing map
| If they bought | Recommend | Why it pairs |
|---|
| SPF 50 Face Cream | Hydrating After-Sun Lotion | Protect by day, repair by night |
| Body SPF 30 | Lip SPF 30 + After-Sun | Covers what body SPF misses |
| Mineral Glow Stick | SPF 50 Face Cream | Stick for top-ups, cream for the base layer |
| Lip SPF 30 | SPF 50 Face Cream | Small first order → full routine |
| Hydrating After-Sun Lotion | SPF 50 Face Cream | Repair buyers need protection next |
Feed settings · xs_after_sun
Recommendation Personalized · products a customer may also like
Based on Purchase + view history
Category filter Includes any of: Pair · After-Sun
Stock filter Minimum 10 units
Fallback Best sellers, last 90 days
Auto-excluded Already purchased · out of stock · no image