Projected impact
What it should be worth.
39%Open rate, up from 11%
0.06%Gmail spam rate, down from 0.41%
+28%Campaign revenue with 76% fewer sends
| Metric | Before | Week 8 |
|---|
| Open rate | 11% | 39% |
| Click rate | 0.3% | 1.9% |
| Gmail spam rate | 0.41% | 0.06% |
| Inbox placement (seed test) | 58% | 94% |
| Mailable profiles | 50,000 | 27,500 |
| Sends per week | 200,000 | ~48,000 |
| Revenue per send | $0.03 | $0.16 |
| Campaign revenue a month | $25,800 | $33,000 |
The maths: Of the 25,000 who entered the sunset flow, 2,500 (10%) were won back and 22,500 were suppressed on day 30. Klaviyo bills on active profiles, so the smaller list can drop the account a pricing tier, which helps pay for the work.
How we would measure it: What keeps it fixed: a weekly Postmaster check, the sunset flow left running permanently, and a rule that no campaign goes to the full list. Open rates include Apple machine opens on both sides, so before and after compare like for like; clicks and revenue are the cleaner proof.
How it's built in Klaviyo and Shopify
Five steps over six weeks, in order. Tighten DMARC before every sender is authenticated and you junk your own order confirmations.
- Week 1 · Inventory every sender: Klaviyo, Shopify, Recharge, Gorgias and Google Workspace all send as @forgeandgrind.com. Each needs SPF or DKIM before DMARC is enforced, and SPF stays under its 10-lookup limit.
- Week 1 · Branded sending domain: mail moves off Klaviyo's shared domain onto send.forgeandgrind.com, with two DKIM selectors and a verification record, then traffic moves over gradually, most engaged first.
- Weeks 1 to 6 · DMARC: reporting first at p=none, then p=quarantine on 25% of failing mail in week 4, then full quarantine in week 6. p=reject comes later, once reports stay clean.
- Weekly · Google Postmaster Tools: domain verified by DNS. Postmaster Tools v2 retired the old reputation charts, so the signals are the Compliance Status dashboard and the spam rate.
- Weeks 2 to 6 · Throttle: Engaged 30 only, then add Engaged 60, then the cooling tier monthly. If the spam rate goes over 0.1%, step back one tier.
The audit
| Check | Found | Status |
|---|
| Sending domain | Klaviyo's shared domain. No reputation of their own. | Fail |
| DKIM alignment | Signed, but not by forgeandgrind.com. | Fail |
| DMARC | p=none with no reporting address. | Weak |
| Other senders | Shopify, Recharge, Gorgias, Google Workspace, never inventoried. | Unknown |
| Google Postmaster Tools | Not set up. Nobody could see the spam rate. | Missing |
| One-click unsubscribe | Present (Klaviyo adds it by default). | Pass |
DNS records (example values)
forgeandgrind.com TXT "v=spf1 include:_spf.google.com include:shops.shopify.com include:<helpdesk> ~all"
send.forgeandgrind.com CNAME <value from Klaviyo>
km1._domainkey CNAME <value from Klaviyo>
km2._domainkey CNAME <value from Klaviyo>
DMARC, staged
; week 1 · monitor
v=DMARC1; p=none; rua=mailto:[email protected]; adkim=r; aspf=r
; week 4 · quarantine a quarter of failing mail
v=DMARC1; p=quarantine; pct=25; rua=mailto:[email protected]; adkim=r; aspf=r
; week 6 · full quarantine
v=DMARC1; p=quarantine; rua=mailto:[email protected]; adkim=r; aspf=r
Segment definitions
Engaged 30 Days = any of, in the last 30 days:
Clicked Email ≥ 1 · Active on Site ≥ 1 · Placed Order ≥ 1
Opened Email ≥ 1 where Apple Privacy Open = false
Engaged 60 Days = same conditions, last 60 days
Unengaged 90+ Days = none of the above in the last 90 days
AND profile created more than 90 days ago
AND rc_active_subscriber is not true