Flow · Forge & Grind · Premium coffee and gear, subscription-first

Getting a coffee brand's emails out of spam.

How Forge & Grind went from 11% opens on a 50,000-person blast to an inbox it could rely on: fix the plumbing first, then shrink the list on purpose.

From 11% opens on a 50,000-person blast to an inbox the brand can rely on.

Projected11% → 39%Projected open rate. Gmail spam rate from 0.41% to 0.06%.
KlaviyoRechargeDNS (SPF · DKIM · DMARC)Google Postmaster Tools
Forge & Grind: Deliverability rescue

If this sounds like your store

Sending more emails and selling less?

Mailing people who stopped opening months ago drags every send into spam, including your reorder reminders. The Flow Gap Review checks for a sunset flow.

Problem, strategy, execution

Deliverability rescue

The problem

Four blasts a week to everyone.

50,000 profiles, half of them silent for 90+ days. Gmail noticed before the team did: a 0.41% spam rate, over Gmail's 0.3% ceiling for bulk senders.

The plumbing

Own the domain, enforce DMARC.

A branded sending domain, DMARC moved to p=quarantine in stages, and alignment confirmed in Google Postmaster Tools.

The list

Rank subscribers by engagement and stop emailing the ones who've gone quiet.

Send by engagement, and run a 30-day sunset flow that wins some people back and lets the rest go.

The flow

Every step, and who goes where.

Engaged 30 days · 12,500Clicked, browsed, ordered, or opened on a device that isn't Apple's privacy proxy, in the last 30 daysUp to 3 campaigns a week: launches, restocks, new roasts
Engaged 60 days · +8,000The same signals, 31 to 60 days agoOne campaign a week: the week's best performer
Unengaged 90+ days · 25,000None of the above in 90 days, and not an active Recharge subscriberNo campaigns. Sunset flow only
  1. triggerEnters segment: Unengaged 90+ days
  2. filterClicked Email = 0 and Placed Order = 0 since starting this flowre-checked before every send
  3. emailE1 · The best of Forge & Grindvalue first: most-read brew guide, newest roast
  4. wait7 days
  5. emailE2 · Too much email?one click to go monthly or roasts-only
  6. wait7 days
  7. emailE3 · Should we stop emailing you?plain-text breakup from the founder
  8. wait16 days
  9. splitEngaged since day 0?

    Yes

    1. exitWon back: rejoins their tier

    No

    1. actionsunset_status = sunsetweekly bulk suppress

Never sunset a paying subscriber: someone on an active Recharge plan who ignores newsletters is still a customer, so the rc_active_subscriber property keeps them out of the sunset segment. The 4,500 "cooling" profiles (61 to 89 days) get two best-of emails a month.

The emails

What customers actually receive.

Desktop and phone, with the job each email does and how it's built.

Forge & Grind email: The breakup email, desktop
The same email on a phone

Sunset email 3 · Day 14

The breakup email

From: Eli at Forge & GrindShould we stop emailing you?Honest question. One click either way.

A/B subject: Is this goodbye?

The job
Get one last honest signal from 25,000 silent profiles, then clean the list.
Why it works
Loss aversion in a human voice, and autonomy: two easy ways to stay, and permission to go.
How it's built
Plain text, one human, no logo or hero. "Keep me" restores their tier; "monthly" sets a frequency property. Both clicks exit the flow. The removal date is the flow's real day-30 check, rendered dynamically. The P.S. invites replies, one of the strongest positive signals a mailbox provider sees.

The other two sunset emails

Day 0The best of Forge & GrindValue first: the most-read brew guide and the newest roast. No discount.
Day 7Too much email?One click to go monthly, roasts-only, or stay as is. Fewer emails beats none.

Projected impact

What it should be worth.

39%Open rate, up from 11%
0.06%Gmail spam rate, down from 0.41%
+28%Campaign revenue with 76% fewer sends
MetricBeforeWeek 8
Open rate11%39%
Click rate0.3%1.9%
Gmail spam rate0.41%0.06%
Inbox placement (seed test)58%94%
Mailable profiles50,00027,500
Sends per week200,000~48,000
Revenue per send$0.03$0.16
Campaign revenue a month$25,800$33,000

The maths: Of the 25,000 who entered the sunset flow, 2,500 (10%) were won back and 22,500 were suppressed on day 30. Klaviyo bills on active profiles, so the smaller list can drop the account a pricing tier, which helps pay for the work.

How we would measure it: What keeps it fixed: a weekly Postmaster check, the sunset flow left running permanently, and a rule that no campaign goes to the full list. Open rates include Apple machine opens on both sides, so before and after compare like for like; clicks and revenue are the cleaner proof.

How it's built in Klaviyo and Shopify

Five steps over six weeks, in order. Tighten DMARC before every sender is authenticated and you junk your own order confirmations.

  1. Week 1 · Inventory every sender: Klaviyo, Shopify, Recharge, Gorgias and Google Workspace all send as @forgeandgrind.com. Each needs SPF or DKIM before DMARC is enforced, and SPF stays under its 10-lookup limit.
  2. Week 1 · Branded sending domain: mail moves off Klaviyo's shared domain onto send.forgeandgrind.com, with two DKIM selectors and a verification record, then traffic moves over gradually, most engaged first.
  3. Weeks 1 to 6 · DMARC: reporting first at p=none, then p=quarantine on 25% of failing mail in week 4, then full quarantine in week 6. p=reject comes later, once reports stay clean.
  4. Weekly · Google Postmaster Tools: domain verified by DNS. Postmaster Tools v2 retired the old reputation charts, so the signals are the Compliance Status dashboard and the spam rate.
  5. Weeks 2 to 6 · Throttle: Engaged 30 only, then add Engaged 60, then the cooling tier monthly. If the spam rate goes over 0.1%, step back one tier.

The audit

CheckFoundStatus
Sending domainKlaviyo's shared domain. No reputation of their own.Fail
DKIM alignmentSigned, but not by forgeandgrind.com.Fail
DMARCp=none with no reporting address.Weak
Other sendersShopify, Recharge, Gorgias, Google Workspace, never inventoried.Unknown
Google Postmaster ToolsNot set up. Nobody could see the spam rate.Missing
One-click unsubscribePresent (Klaviyo adds it by default).Pass

DNS records (example values)

forgeandgrind.com          TXT    "v=spf1 include:_spf.google.com include:shops.shopify.com include:<helpdesk> ~all"
send.forgeandgrind.com     CNAME  <value from Klaviyo>
km1._domainkey             CNAME  <value from Klaviyo>
km2._domainkey             CNAME  <value from Klaviyo>

DMARC, staged

; week 1 · monitor
v=DMARC1; p=none; rua=mailto:[email protected]; adkim=r; aspf=r

; week 4 · quarantine a quarter of failing mail
v=DMARC1; p=quarantine; pct=25; rua=mailto:[email protected]; adkim=r; aspf=r

; week 6 · full quarantine
v=DMARC1; p=quarantine; rua=mailto:[email protected]; adkim=r; aspf=r

Segment definitions

Engaged 30 Days = any of, in the last 30 days:
  Clicked Email ≥ 1 · Active on Site ≥ 1 · Placed Order ≥ 1
  Opened Email ≥ 1 where Apple Privacy Open = false
Engaged 60 Days = same conditions, last 60 days
Unengaged 90+ Days = none of the above in the last 90 days
  AND profile created more than 90 days ago
  AND rc_active_subscriber is not true

The 48-Hour Repeat Revenue Audit · free

Which of these is your store missing?

The free audit shows where your customers stop buying after order #1, which flows are missing or mistimed, and our estimate of what it's likely costing you. Back in 48 hours.

Get your free 48-hour audit