Campaign · Forge & Grind · Premium coffee and gear, subscription-first

A newsletter people actually read.

Forge & Grind's weekly newsletter: text-first, editorial, no pitch. One idea in about 200 words, written so the reader can act on it before their next cup.

A 200-word letter every Sunday, built to read like mail from a person.

Projected70–80%Projected Gmail Primary placement on seed tests, with ~120 replies an issue.
KlaviyoFigma
Forge & Grind: The Sunday Brew newsletter

If this sounds like your store

Campaigns that only ever sell?

A weekly letter people want to open keeps you in the Primary tab, so the emails that do sell actually get seen.

The plan

When it goes out, and to whom.

Every Sunday · 7am localOne issue, one ideaEngaged 60 only, in the recipient's time zone
Before each sendSeed-list testShows which Gmail tab it lands in. If it slips to Promotions, trim links and images first
Every weekRead the signalsPostmaster spam rate under 0.1%, reply count and click rate

Who gets it

  • Engaged 60 days: about 20,500 people who clicked, browsed, ordered or genuinely opened recently

Who's left out, and why

  • Unengaged 90+ (the sunset flow handles them)
  • Anyone who opted out of the newsletter

The emails

What customers actually receive.

Desktop and phone, with the job each email does and how it's built.

Forge & Grind email: Why your coffee tastes sour, desktop
The same email on a phone

Issue 42 · Sunday 7am

Why your coffee tastes sour

From: Eli at Forge & GrindWhy your coffee tastes sour (the 5-second fix)It's almost never the beans.

A/B subject: It's not the beans

The job
Be worth opening every week, so the weeks that do sell land in an inbox that trusts the brand.
Why it works
Ritual and reciprocity: same slot, same voice, real help. The only commercial line is the last link, and it's soft.
How it's built
About 80% text and 20% image, one photo, under 50KB of HTML, inline CSS in a single column, three links on one domain, text links instead of buttons, and a written plain-text part. "What number is your grinder on?" invites replies, which feed next week's issue.

Projected impact

What it should be worth.

3.2%Click rate per issue
~120Replies per issue
<0.02%Spam complaints
Per issue · 20,500 engagedProjected
Gmail Primary placement (seed test)70–80%
Click rate3.2%
Replies~120
Unsubscribe rate0.08%
Spam complaintsunder 0.02%

How we would measure it: Open rate is the weakest signal, because Apple's privacy proxy inflates it. And if it lands in Promotions anyway? Readers who open it every Sunday still find it there, and their opens and replies keep the domain healthy. Primary is a bonus. Being worth opening is the strategy.

How it's built in Klaviyo and Shopify

Honest framing first: Gmail decides tabs with its own models, weighing content, sender history and how readers behave. No layout guarantees Primary. The job is to look and act like a letter, then measure where it lands.

    The build, the voice, the habit

    SettingWhy
    Text to image≈ 80/20, one photoReads like a letter, not a flyer
    HTML weightUnder 50KBGmail clips at 102KB; this leaves room for tracking and keeps the unsubscribe visible
    CSSInline, single columnRenders the same everywhere
    Links and buttons3 links max, one domain, text linksFewer promotional signals
    From nameEli at Forge & GrindA person, with a monitored reply-to
    LanguageNo "% off", "sale" or "shop now" in the subject or previewIt's a newsletter; the words say so
    Send time and audienceSunday 7am local, Engaged 60 onlyThe same slot trains readers and Gmail; engaged tiers keep the spam rate near zero

    The 48-Hour Repeat Revenue Audit · free

    Which of these is your store missing?

    The free audit shows where your customers stop buying after order #1, which flows are missing or mistimed, and our estimate of what it's likely costing you. Back in 48 hours.

    Get your free 48-hour audit