BFCM program · Morrow & Root · Supplements

Black Friday that keeps new customers past order #1.

A 28-email Black Friday program for a supplement brand. It welcomes the first-time buyers the sale brings in, times their reorder by how much they bought, and gives each existing customer the offer that fits them, instead of 25% off to everyone.

The sale is the easy part. The money is in who comes back in January.

ShopifyKlaviyo28 emails2 flows + 7 campaigns
Morrow & Root BFCM customer journey board

If this sounds like your store

How many of last year's Black Friday buyers ordered again by March?

BFCM brings in the biggest wave of first-time customers of the year, and most stores never see them again. The audit's Churn Point Analysis shows how each cohort, including last November's, dropped off, and what it's likely costing you.

The problem

Four ways a normal Black Friday leaks money.

New buyers vanishThe sale brings in first-time customers, and nothing teaches them to use the product.

They finish the bottle, never build the habit, and don't reorder.

Discounts to loyal customers25% off to people who would have paid full price.

Your best customers stock up at the deepest discount of the year.

Wrong emails to gift buyers“How are you finding your magnesium?” to someone who gave it away.

It reads as careless, and the buyer tunes out.

Inbox pressureA dozen emails in a week.

Unsubscribes spike, and the reorder reminders in January land in spam.

Flow 1 · BFCM welcome

First-time buyers, split by who the order was for.

Self-buyers learn how to take it and hear from the founder. Gift buyers get delivery updates, then an offer for themselves. A random 20% get none of it, so the lift can be read against them.

  1. triggerFirst-ever order, Nov 24 to Dec 2Shopify → Klaviyo
  2. filter20% random holdoutkept out of the flow, so the lift can be read against them
  3. splitTagged gift-bfcm26 at checkout?

    No · bought for themselves

    1. emailA1 · Thanks for your first orderright after the order
    2. emailA2 · How to take your supplementson delivery
    3. emailA3 · How is it going?day 14, a note from founder Dana Morrow
    4. emailA4 · A quick reviewday 28
    5. emailA6 · What pairs wellday 60, matched to the first product

    Yes · bought as a gift

    1. emailG1 · Your order is confirmedno how-to-take emails
    2. emailG2 · Your order has been deliveredon delivery
    3. emailG3 · An offer for themselvesday 40

Flow 2 · Stock-up-aware reorder

Reminders timed by how much they bought.

A Black Friday buyer who stocked up on three tubs doesn't need a reminder in three weeks. The flow reads the quantity and waits until they're about a week from running out.

  1. triggerPlaced order, supplementsquantity read from the order
  2. splitHow many units?

    1 unit

    1. wait23 days
    2. emailR1 · Running low?
    3. wait7 days
    4. emailR2 · A reminder

    2 units

    1. wait53 days
    2. emailR1 · Running low?
    3. wait7 days
    4. emailR2 · A reminder

    3+ units

    1. wait83 days
    2. emailR1 · Running low?
    3. wait7 days
    4. emailR2 · A reminder
  3. exitPlaced another orderthe reminders stop

Campaigns 10 to 16 · Offers by customer type

Each customer gets the offer they need, not the deepest one.

Three unique codes, so an offer can't be shared down a tier, and a cap of five to six emails per person across the whole week.

Loyal customers

10% + a free tin

BFCM26_LOYAL

They were going to buy anyway. A thank-you, not a fire sale.

One-time buyers

15% off

BFCM26_ONETIME

Enough to bring back someone who bought once and drifted.

Everyone else

25% off

BFCM26_MAIN

The headline sale, for people who haven't bought yet.

Left out of every campaign

  • Anyone who has ordered since November 24. Stop selling to someone who just bought.
  • Anyone unengaged for 180 days, to protect deliverability for January.
  • Wholesale accounts, and anyone with an open support ticket.

The strategy boards

The whole program on six boards.

Tap any board to see it full size.

The emails

12 of the 28 emails.

Tap any email to read it in full.

Projected impact

What it's built to move, for a $100k-a-month store.

6-month repeat rate, BFCM cohort

16% 22%

Target, from welcome and reorder timing.

Discount given to existing customers

$9,400 $7,140

From offers by customer type, instead of 25% to everyone.

The 48-Hour Repeat Revenue Audit · free

Find out what last year's sale really kept.

The free audit shows how each cohort dropped off after order #1, which flows should have caught them, and our estimate of what it's likely costing you. Back in 48 hours.

Get your free 48-hour audit